So a while ago I noticed some posts in the ANT+ forum by Mark Rages. Turns out he’s the “electronics guru” of Quarq. He has an old tumblr site here. Where he shows an MSP430 + the ANT+ AP2 module to use as an intermediary and convert old SRM powermeters to ANT+.
This is like my ANT+ to BT2.0 for another purpose… a much more complicated issue too. If you have an old SRM this should be very useful to you!
Image from markrages.tumblr.com
This is impressive! He’s gotten power consumption down to 160 microamps from a coin cell. He’s a much more experienced man than I in regards to this stuff.
There was also a discussion on Facebook’s “Training with power” surrounding ANT+ head units. Mark’s post in the ANT+ forum was removed or I can’t find it, however the opensource.quarq.us site still exists with his python scripts for ANTware II. It’s located here.
A big shout out and thanks are deserved for Mark I think. Cheers and thanks for promoting ANT+.
It's a cool-looking project. I downloaded his code to play around with it, but it won't compile for the chip he says he is using due to the size of the compiled code. I've got an email out to him to see if he's using a different toolchain than me, or has some sort of black magic incantation that needs to be whispered before running make.
ReplyDeleteI've tried to contact Mark a couple of times without success. He popped up with a lot of stuff around the time he made the post, and then very quickly disappeared from involvement with the ANT+ forum.
DeleteThat's too bad about the code not compiling. Maybe the chip he listed isn't the correct one?
Keith Hack: Convert Your Old Srm Power Meter To Ant+ >>>>> Download Now
Delete>>>>> Download Full
Keith Hack: Convert Your Old Srm Power Meter To Ant+ >>>>> Download LINK
>>>>> Download Now
Keith Hack: Convert Your Old Srm Power Meter To Ant+ >>>>> Download Full
>>>>> Download LINK ML
Mark and I have corresponded briefly. He's been extremely helpful both on the software front as well as offering suggestions for working with the SMDs he specified in his layout.
ReplyDeleteThe object file, even with the most aggressive compiler optimization, is frustratingly 50 bytes too big to fit in the MPS430g2231 memory. Mark suggested using another msp430 with identical pinouts - I've been able to compile for the 2302, 2312 and several others and get the code to run in my emulator. I've got a 2312 on order for my launchpad as well as the other parts. If I can get things to work on a breadboard I'll order a few of the PCBs per Mark's design and see if I can get my 2 wired SRMs talking to a garmin.
I don't know how embedded software guys can do this every day. I've never had to worry about 50B of text in one of my executables before :)
Hey John, im trying this project as well. Ive ordered the necessary parts and am going to attempt to recreate the project. Will you be posting your results anywhere? If you dont mind, i would love to keep track as it may help me complete my chip as well.
DeleteLuckily I've never been so limited, but this sounds frustrating... maybe even infuriating! I'm moving my design to the nRF51 as the transceiver is built in with the ARM core. It seems quite flush with memory so hopefully I don't start running into similar problems.
ReplyDeleteIf you have some success John, I'd love to hear about it. Keep in touch. It looks like such a useful project that if I could get an old wired SRM unit I'd consider building it so I'm hoping to hear you've been successful.
Being an owner of 4 older SRM's, these projects are of great personal interest to me. I bought a couple MSP430's, and some ANT+ modules. I'm waiting for the modules to arrive (Wednesday) to see if I can make it work. Looking through your most current project, I'd love to help in any way I can.
ReplyDeleteThere seems to be a decent amount of interest in this. I've gotten several emails about it. If you get anywhere I'd love if you could email me and let me know. Several times talk of needing to use a different chip than Mark did has come up with people I've talked with -- lack of memory. There might be a drop in replacement. Anyway, keep us / me informed if you have a chance.
DeleteI don't pretend to be an engineer. I am decent at reverse engineering and copying. I'm primarily a cyclist and a very experienced coach. Parts came in today. Let's see what happens.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGreat! If you ever hit the market, I have two older wired SRM and would surely get these convertion systems!
ReplyDeleteHello Keith, How's your project going with the SRM convertion to wireless ? I've been looking for something like this for awhile. I was thinking about doing same thing use a Bluetooth chip. Would love to hear how are you doing on this. Thanks
ReplyDeleteHi, I wonder if anyone who attempted the building would have any additional information to share here. Since there were no follow ups I tend to believe no one succeeded - is that the case ?
ReplyDeleteHi!
ReplyDeleteI have managed to compile the code into G2452, which has identical pin layout. However, now having problems with the communication as the default firmware is not connecting to any ANT computer. Also looking for a code to test if the AP2 module itself is communicating with msp430.
Any updates in 2020?)
ReplyDeleteI got a breadboard version working in 2013. I used mark's gerber files to get 5 boards from pcbatch. I fried 3 of them (or the SMDs) and then finally got one working once my reflow toaster oven got dialed in. that was in 2014. Note that two kids, a dog, a wife and very little expertise in devices probably conspired to slow my progress. Once I had a working unit I looked at costs of scaling up and getting someone else to mount the f**king SMDs. Assuming a quantity of 100, the BOM was something like $30 and assembly costs were outrageously high due to the quantity. I don't remember exactly but IIRC it was like $280/ea. They really don't like setting up for low volume runs. At that point I said phooey and decided to move on to different projects. With the price of dual-leg power meters now under $600 I don't se much reason to dive back into this from a commercial perspective, but if anyone is really jonesing to dive in I'm still happy to offer what assistance I can after this much time.
ReplyDeleteHi John, I'd be interested in giving this a crack, if it's something I can manage. I have 3 wired SRMs and would love to be able to convert at least one to ANT+, in particular the one on my trainer bike.
DeleteBut I'd be coming at this from a low knowledge base (i.e. bugger all) of setting up circuit boards and programming chips. I could probably manage a simple soldering job OK.
What do I need? Is there a guide I can read?
Hi Alex,
DeleteI had an extensive reply typed out and somehow didn't manage to post it. I'm not feeling up to trying to replicate so if you don't mind, would you look me up on LinkedIn? There aren't many people named John Bravenec, so you should be able to find the real me with little effort. Happy to share my thoughts over messaging or email.
Hi John, I'm having trouble connecting via Linkedin. Says I need a Premium account to message people and it's not a service I use. Any alternative? Thanks, Alex
DeleteIf there's a chance of Keith leading a few of us through this design I'd also like to get onboard. I have a couple of powermeters in the spares bin and some young kids who want to play Zwift with me.
ReplyDeleteHi Michael,
ReplyDeleteYou should probably check out the link Keith posted to the project to determine whether or not it's something you could take on. TL;DR, unless you have electronics and embedded devices experience, you should look elsewhere. Plus, my understanding from this blog is Keith is working on other projects. Witness the lack of new content on this subject in the last 8 years.